The True Story Behind ‘The Green Book’ Movie

Create an image of a classic car from the 1960s parked in front of a small, inviting motel with a neon sign that reads Welcome! Listed in The Green Book. The setting is a peaceful twilight, with a diverse group of travelers gathering around the car, exchanging stories and laughter, underscoring the sense of community and safety provided by The Green Book during segregation-era America.

The True Story Behind ‘The Green Book’ Movie

The 2018 Oscar-winning film, The Green Book, not only entertained audiences worldwide but also brought to light a relatively unknown chapter of American history. Directed by Peter Farrelly, this film tells the story of African-American pianist Dr. Don Shirley and his Italian-American driver and bodyguard, Tony Lip, during their tour through the segregated American South in the early 1960s. However, as with any depiction of historical events through cinema, it’s crucial to differentiate between artistic interpretation and factual accuracy. The true story behind The Green Book movie involves not only the two main characters but also the broader historical context of segregation in the United States and the actual Green Book that served as a travel guide for African-American motorists.

The Historical Context and The Real Green Book

Before delving into the personal journeys of Dr. Don Shirley and Tony Lip, understanding the era in which their story took place is essential. The Green Book, officially titled The Negro Motorist Green Book, was first published in 1936 by Harlem-based postman Victor Hugo Green. Initially covering only the New York area, it soon expanded to cover much of North America. Its purpose was to provide African-American travelers with information on hotels, restaurants, service stations, and other facilities where they would be welcomed, essentially helping them navigate the perils of Jim Crow laws and local customs enforcing racial segregation.

By the time Dr. Shirley and Tony Lip embarked on their tour in 1962, the Civil Rights Movement was in full swing, challenging segregation and discrimination across the United States. Their trip, therefore, was not just a simple journey through the South but a navigation of the deeply entrenched racial divides of the time.

The Real-Life Characters: Dr. Don Shirley and Tony Lip

Dr. Don Shirley was a renowned pianist, known for his mastery over classical, jazz, and popular music. Contrary to the portrayal in the movie as somewhat estranged from his family, reports suggest that he was in fact in touch with his relatives. His experiences of racism and isolation were, however, very real, contributing to the complexity of his character.

Tony Lip, born Frank Anthony Vallelonga, was indeed a bouncer at the Copacabana club in New York before being hired as Dr. Shirley’s driver. The film accurately captures his street-smart persona and gradual transformation as he confronts the realities of racial prejudice firsthand. Despite some creative liberties taken with their interactions and the dynamics of their relationship, the core element of mutual respect and friendship that develops between them is grounded in truth.

The Controversies and Criticisms

While The Green Book movie received critical acclaim and won several awards, it was not without its controversies. Members of Dr. Shirley’s family contested various aspects of his portrayal, stating that the relationship between Dr. Shirley and Tony Lip was exaggerated and that Dr. Shirley had never been estranged from his family. Critics also pointed out the movie’s tendency to oversimplify complex racial issues through a white savior lens. Despite these criticisms, the film succeeded in shedding light on a significant yet overlooked aspect of American history—the existence and purpose of the real Green Book.

FAQs About ‘The Green Book’ and Its True Story

What was the original purpose of The Negro Motorist Green Book?

The Negro Motorist Green Book was created to provide African-American travelers with a guide to businesses across the United States that were safe and welcoming to them during an era of strict racial segregation. It included listings for hotels, motels, gas stations, restaurants, and even private homes that were willing to accommodate black travelers, making it an invaluable resource for safely navigating the country.

How true to life is the portrayal of Dr. Don Shirley and Tony Lip’s relationship in the movie?

While the fundamental basis of the friendship between Dr. Don Shirley and Tony Lip in the movie is rooted in reality, several aspects of their relationship and the events during their tour were dramatized or fictionalized for cinematic purposes. For instance, the depth of their bond and the timeline of their friendship were condensed to fit the film’s narrative. Members of Dr. Shirley’s family, particularly his brother, have contested the portrayal of their relationship as being closer in the film than it might have been in reality.

Did Tony Lip really work at the Copacabana?

Yes, Tony Lip indeed worked at the Copacabana, a famous nightclub in New York City, before taking the job to drive and protect Dr. Don Shirley on his tour through the South. This aspect of the story is accurately portrayed in the movie, demonstrating Tony Lip’s background and introducing viewers to his character’s world.

What impact did The Green Book have on American society?

The Green Book had a significant impact on American society by providing African-American travelers with the resources needed to navigate a segregated country safely. It not only offered practical information but also a sense of dignity and autonomy in an era when racism and discrimination severely restricted the freedoms of black Americans. Moreover, its legacy continues to inform discussions on race, travel, and equality in America.

Why has The Green Book become a significant symbol in American history?

The Green Book has become a significant symbol in American history because it represents both the reality of racial segregation and the resilience of the African-American community during the Jim Crow era. It stands as a testament to the efforts of black Americans to claim their right to travel freely and safely in their own country. Furthermore, it highlights the broader struggle for civil rights and equality, making it an enduring symbol of resistance against oppression.

Did the movie receive any major criticisms?

Yes, The Green Book movie faced major criticisms, particularly regarding its approach to and representation of racial issues. Some argued that the movie perpetuated a white savior narrative that undermined the severity of racism Dr. Shirley faced and simplified the complex dynamics of race relations. Additionally, the backlash from Dr. Shirley’s family regarding factual inaccuracies and the portrayal of his character and relationships also garnered significant attention. These criticisms sparked broader conversations about representation and storytelling in Hollywood.

What happened to The Green Book after the Civil Rights Act of 1964?

After the Civil Rights Act of 1964 was enacted, providing legal protection against discrimination in public accommodations and facilities, The Green Book gradually lost its immediate relevance and necessity. Victor Green had envisioned a time when his book would no longer be needed, hoping for an integrated society where African Americans could freely travel without fear of discrimination. The last edition was published in 1966, marking the end of an era but leaving a lasting legacy on the importance of safe and dignified travel for all.

The story of The Green Book movie and the real history behind it offer a poignant look into a challenging yet pivotal time in American history. By understanding the true story and the context in which Dr. Don Shirley and Tony Lip navigated their journey, audiences can appreciate not only the narrative’s complexities but also the broader lessons about race, friendship, and the enduring struggle for equality.

AMAZON — Today’s Deals

Leave a Reply